How to Tell if Your Pool Pump Needs Repair or Replacement

Your pool pump is the heart of your pool’s circulation system. It keeps the water moving, pushes it through filters, and helps distribute chemicals evenly. When it’s working right, you probably don’t think twice about it—but when it’s not, your entire pool system can quickly fall out of balance.

At Pallett Pool and Spa, we often get calls from Mississauga pool owners wondering if their pump is acting up—or if it's time for a full replacement. Here’s how to tell whether your pump needs a repair or if it’s time to invest in a new one.

Signs Your Pool Pump Needs Attention

1. Strange Noises

If your pump is making grinding, screeching, or rattling sounds, it’s a sign something’s wrong. This could mean worn bearings, debris inside the impeller, or a failing motor. Sometimes, replacing a few parts can fix the issue—other times, especially if the motor is damaged, replacement may be more cost-effective.

2. Low Water Flow or Poor Circulation

Is your pool water staying cloudy, or are the skimmers not pulling in debris like they used to? Low flow can point to a clogged filter, an air leak, or a failing pump. If the pump’s motor is running but you’re not getting proper circulation, it’s time to get it inspected.

3. Pump Won’t Start or Turns Off Unexpectedly

If your pump won’t turn on—or starts, then shuts off—there could be an electrical issue, a faulty capacitor, or an overheating motor. These issues can often be repaired if caught early, but consistent electrical failure may mean the motor is near the end of its lifespan.

4. Visible Leaks

Water leaking from the pump housing or seals is a common issue. Sometimes it's a simple fix, like replacing a worn-out seal. But if leaks are combined with rust, corrosion, or age-related wear, replacing the pump may be the smarter option.

5. Higher Than Usual Energy Bills

Older pool pumps, especially single-speed models, are often inefficient and can drive up your hydro bills. If your energy costs are rising without a clear cause, your pump may be working too hard—or running longer than it should to achieve proper circulation.

Repair vs. Replace: Which Makes More Sense?

• Repair Your Pump If:

  • The issue is minor (e.g. seal, capacitor, impeller).

  • The motor is less than 5 years old.

  • The housing and internal parts are in good condition.

  • It’s a newer, energy-efficient model.

• Replace Your Pump If:

  • Repairs are becoming frequent or costly.

  • The motor is old, noisy, or overheating.

  • The pump doesn’t meet your pool’s current needs (e.g., added features, increased size).

  • You want to upgrade to a more efficient variable-speed pump and reduce energy usage.

Why Choose Pallett Pool and Spa for Pump Repair or Replacement?

At Pallett Pool and Spa, we’ve been servicing Mississauga-area pools for years. Our technicians can quickly diagnose your pump issue, explain your options clearly, and help you decide whether repair or replacement makes the most sense—based on both function and cost.

We carry and install high-efficiency pumps from trusted manufacturers and stand behind our work with expert advice and dependable service.

Book Your Pool Pump Inspection Today

If your pool pump isn’t performing the way it used to, don’t wait for it to fail completely. Call Pallett Pool and Spa today to schedule a service visit. We’ll help you keep your water clean, your system efficient, and your summer stress-free.